Delegates to the Republican State Convention:
We, as members of
the Rules and Procedures Committee of the Maine Republican Party,
endorse the adoption of Rule 16.0, which codifies the longstanding use
of a plurality as the basis for determining the winners of Maine
Republican primary elections and rejects the substitution of ranked
choice voting as the standard. We do so for many important reasons.
Plurality Voting Works.
Plurality voting is tested, tried, and proven. It is part of the
Party’s proud history that plurality voting was enshrined in the Maine
Constitution after General Joshua Chamberlain, one Maine’s greatest
Republican statesmen, rescued the State from civil war over an election
dispute. Since that day, the rule of law has prevailed in Maine
elections.
Plurality voting remains the best process for
selecting nominees. The Party has used plurality voting to select its
nominees for decades – and it works. Plurality voting is a simple,
understandable system that allows election results to be known
promptly. It is transparent, as it can be carried out in towns and
municipalities with local oversight. And it is fair, minimizing
confusion and the possibility that ballots will be disqualified.
Plurality voting protects the legitimacy of the Party’s primary process.
Ranked Choice Voting Is Inferior.
In contrast to the many benefits of plurality voting, ranked choice
voting will threaten the legitimacy of the Party’s primary. Ranked
choice voting:
- Is unconstitutional;
- Is complicated, leading to potential voter confusion and vote suppression;
- Does not provide sufficient transparency and local control over ballot counting;
- Is less secure than plurality voting, undermining confidence in our election system;
- Will lead to unnecessary delays in determining the outcome of the Party’s primary.
In
order to maintain the integrity of the Party’s primary, we believe
plurality voting, not ranked choice voting, should be used to select the
Party’s nominees.
Choosing Party Nominees Matters. The
most important activity the Maine Republican Party does is choose
candidates to run for elected federal and state offices. These
candidates represent the values, ideals, and policies that the members
of the Republican Party believe to be best for our country and for our
beautiful State.
As recognized leaders of the Party,
candidates convey the Republican message to Maine voters, help define
the Republican platform, and labor tirelessly after their election to
carry out the public policies that their constituents elected them to
accomplish. It is therefore vitally important that the Party choose its
nominees using a process that is fair, transparent, and workable.
Thank you.
The Rules and Procedures Committee
Annalee Rosenblatt, Chair, Cumberland
Ann Amadon, Somerset
Cindy Nesbit, Sagadahoc
Kim E MPettengill, Kennebec
Michael Quatrano, Cumberland
Ann Robinson, Esq., Cumberland
Dr. Demi Kouzounas ex officio